The vision behind this recipe was a deconstructed (pickled) potato salad using potatoes, celery, shallots (or red onion), garlic, dill and mustard (seeds and ground). I’m pretty pleased with the results, especially given the very limited inspiration I found online for pickled potatoes (a.k.a., they don’t really exist in other people’s pickle repertoires).

This pickled potato recipe was also inspired by a recent trip to where else but Ireland – I didn’t come across any pickled potatoes there but definitely potatoes in pretty much every other form imaginable. I hope you find these as spud-tacular as I did! Make them asap for your favorite spud muffin.
And a final note – how adorbs are these tiny potatoes from Trader Joe’s?! You could use any kind of potato for these (they’re basically fingerlings) but I’m a big fan of the aptly named “Teeny Tiny” varietal.
Pickled Potato Recipe
Makes 1 quart
Ingredients:

- 1 cup water
- 1 cup white wine vinegar
- 1 tsp sugar
- 2 tbsp kosher salt
- 1/2 tsp ground mustard
- 1 tsp mustard seeds
- 1 tsp black peppercorns
- 4 sprigs dill sprigs
- 4 garlic cloves
- 1-2 small shallots
- 2 celery stalks
- 1 lb potatoes (fingerling or other small varietal require less chopping prep – you want the pieces relatively bite-sized)
- Water for boiling potatoes
Instructions:
- Bring a pot of water (enough to cover the potatoes) to a boil. Add rinsed (and still whole) potatoes, turn off stove and soak in hot water for 8 minutes.
- While potatoes are soaking, halve garlic cloves and chop shallots and celery into desired pieces.

- After 8 minutes, drain and rinse potatoes under cool water.
- Add spices ground mustard, mustard seeds and peppercorns to jar, as well as 2 sprigs dill and about half of the chopped garlic, shallot and celery.

- Bring the water, vinegar, sugar and salt to a boil until sugar and salt are fully dissolved. Set aside to cool.

- Slice potatoes into desired pieces (I halved the “teeny tiny” potatoes), trimming any ends and/or other less desirable parts. Add about half of the potatoes to the jar, then add the remaining garlic, shallots and celery (you’re going for the layered effect).

- Add the remaining cut potatoes for a final layer.

- Top with final 2 sprigs of dill and cover all contents with cooled brine. Shake to distribute spices.

- Recommended use: These are great on their own (plus have additional pickled bits with the celery and shallots). I also think they’d be great in a fresh salad as a brighter, lighter version of adding something heavier/denser like roasted potatoes. Definitely need a few days to properly pickle and I would suggest eating within a month because the potato will start to break down a bit.


Pingback:Week 35: Pickled Corn | The Weekly Pickle